diff --git a/Source/Game/Achievements/CriteriaHandler.cs b/Source/Game/Achievements/CriteriaHandler.cs
index b55df56d5..eceb055d9 100644
--- a/Source/Game/Achievements/CriteriaHandler.cs
+++ b/Source/Game/Achievements/CriteriaHandler.cs
@@ -188,9 +188,11 @@ namespace Game.Achievements
                 case CriteriaType.HighestHealReceived:
                 case CriteriaType.AnyArtifactPowerRankPurchased:
                 case CriteriaType.AzeriteLevelReached:
-                case CriteriaType.ReachRenownLevel:
                     SetCriteriaProgress(criteria, miscValue1, referencePlayer, ProgressType.Highest);
                     break;
+                case CriteriaType.ReachRenownLevel:
+                    SetCriteriaProgress(criteria, miscValue2, referencePlayer, ProgressType.Highest);
+                    break;
                 case CriteriaType.ReachLevel:
                     SetCriteriaProgress(criteria, referencePlayer.GetLevel(), referencePlayer);
                     break;